I was asked recently if any of the companies advertising relief from timeshares are legitimate. I had to answer "I don't know if ANY are legitimate, but I don't know of any legitimate ones. What can you do if you are in a timeshare that you can't afford? Can a lawyer help?
Can a lawyer help? The honest answer is sometimes. For almost 17 years I worked for UAW Legal Services Plans, and when I was there I got to help a lot of people with timeshare problems, and the best thing is that I didn't have to charge them a dime, because the UAW Legal Services Plan was an employee benefit. I went back into private practice in 2014, and since then I haven't gotten a lot of calls about timeshares, but there are signs things are picking up. As a private lawyer though, I have to treat timeshare cases like any other case, and I have to get paid. I like to get results for my clients though. Sometimes you can do that with a timeshare and sometimes you can't.
In the paragraphs below, I discuss my methodology of analyzing and remedying timeshare problems. As you read this, contrast this methodology vs the promises of a timeshare relief company. An ethical lawyer doesn't promise results. An ethical lawyer lawyer treats every case differently. An ethical lawyer puts any prepaid fee in the trust account until he or she performs the work. An ethical lawyer informs the client what he/she did to earn the fee.
EASIEST CASES - DEEDED INTEREST - CONTRACT UP TO DATE
When analyzing timeshare cases the first thing I do is look to see if the contract is in default or if it is up-to-date. If it is up-to-date, these are the cases most likely to get relief on an affordable basis. If it is a deeded interest and the contract is up to date, and if the timeshare company is one of the more reputable ones (everything is relative), I suggest the consumer send a letter to the timeshare company claiming economic hardship and offering to sign back over the timeshare to the company in exchange for being let out of the contract going forward. Often the timeshare company will honor this request, and will send you a quitclaim deed to get you out of your timeshare. You may not even need assistance of an attorney to help you, and it you do, it may be just to look over the paperwork. ( If you have a problem in doing this because you think you should get cash money for your timeshare, then good luck to you, your odds of being disappointed are pretty close to 100%. Your odds of being scammed by a time share selling company approach 100%.)
HARDER CASE - CONTRACT UP TO DATE NON-DEEDED INTEREST OR POINTS MODEL
A hardship letter might work in this case as well, but there is more incentive to back it up with an attorney letter just to let the timeshare company know that it might be more expensive for them to fight you than to just give in. In these cases, I typically do an analysis of the sale under the Timeshare Act and point out any potential illegalities in the sale.
HARDEST CASES - CONTRACT NOT UP TO DATE - DEEDED OR NON-DEEDED INTEREST
If you are behind on your contract, annual fees, or both, there's no simple answer. Each one of these cases are different. How I approach the case depends upon how the potential client comes to me. If he or she comes to me because he/she is getting a dunning letter from a collection agency, I first look at whether the collection agency might have violated the Fair Debt Collection Practices Act. Why? Because if I can spot a Fair Debt Collection Practices Act violation, I might be able to represent the consumer at no out-of-pocket fee.
If the person comes to me because he or she is being dunned for overdue timeshare bills by the company and just wants out, I have to interview the consumer in great detail and look at the documents to see if I can spot a violation of the Indiana Timeshare and Camping Club Act (most states have something similar), Indiana Code 32-32-3-1 et seq. This is a time-consuming process and typically costs at least $600. If I spot a potential violation, I typically start a letter-writing process, and my fee depends upon the amount of time needed to complete the objective. Note: if you are paying monthly on a contract, even to a finance company, if you have a valid claim against the seller, you can raise the claim as a defense to paying the finance company under the FTC Holder Rule. I don't suggest that you stop paying the finance company unless it is under the active advice and monitoring of an attorney.
WHAT TO DO IF YOU ARE BEING SUED BY A TIMESHARE COMPANY OR COLLECTOR FOR A TIMESHARE COMPANY
Don't give up! If you are being sued over a timeshare debt, it is crucial that you have the lawsuit documents reviewed by an experienced consumer lawyer. You can find one through the National Association of Consumer Advocates' "Find an Attorney" web page. Please don't call me if you don't reside in Indiana or if the timeshare is not in Indiana. If you are in Indiana though, I welcome your call.
Lawsuits by timeshare companies can often be fought off and resolved for less than what they are claiming from you, including attorney fees. In addition, an attorney can often negotiate payment plans that are less than could be garnished from you if they get a judgment against you. An attorney can evaluate whether bankruptcy is an option for you. Occasionally, attorneys can get back money you already paid or even extra damages for illegal conduct.
WHAT IF I HAVE ALREADY BEEN SCAMMED BY A TIMESHARE RELIEF COMPANY?
If you have been scammed by a timeshare selling or timeshare relief company, contact a consumer attorney through the link above. If the attorney can spot fraud or other illegal activity, the attorney might take the case on a contingency fee basis, meaning, he/she might take the case based on a fee to be recovered from the other side. You should also file a complaint with the attorney general's office in your state and in the state where the scammer is operated.
A blog covering legal topics and whatever I feel like posting. Some posts on this page could be considered to be attorney advertisements.
About The Consumer Law Office of Steve Hofer
Steve Hofer has been practicing consumer law in Indiana for more than 20 years. He is a former Indiana State Chairperson of the National Association of Consumer Advocates, a national organization of attorneys striving for fairness in the consumer marketplace. Contact me by phone at 317-662-4529 or via email at hoferlawindyATgmail.com. You can also leave a message through my website at www.hoferlawindy.com.
Tuesday, March 14, 2017
Thursday, March 2, 2017
The New "Maggot Mile": Debt Relief Companies in Boca Raton, Florida
For a while, in the late 1980s, I lived in South Florida. At that time, penny stock fraud was a huge problem, and some of the sleaziest penny stock brokerage houses operated out of sweatshop call centers set up in Boca Raton, Florida. Because all of these brokerages were so close to each other, the area developed the nickname "Maggot Row", sometimes called "The Maggot Mile". It looks like the maggots have switched to a new industry, "debt relief". I put it in quotations because I don't think a lot of their customers feel very relieved.
Boca Raton Florida has an estimated population of around 92,000 people. Look at all the "debt relief" companies that came up on a simple search at manta.com.
1st National Credit Services Corporation
Absolute Debt Solution
Accelerated Debt Consolidation
Acci Inc.
Advanced Credit Solutions Inc.
American Consolidated Debt
American Corporate Turnaround, Inc.
American Debt
American Debt Negotiators
American Debt Settlement Solutions, Inc.
Amerifinancial Solutions, LLC
A Plus Financial Solutions
Bmv Corporation
Capital Debt Relief
Clear Debt
Consumer Credit Counseling Service
Consumer Credit Counseling Service of South Florida
Consumer Debt Counselor Group
Consumer Debt Counselor Group LLC
Credicare Credit Counseling
Credit Repair
Credit Repair Doctor
Credit Restoration
Dartmouth Foundation, Inc.
Debt B Gone
Debt Franchise Inc.
Debt Management Solutions
Debtmet LLC
Debt Pro Assoc LLC
Debt Relief Group Inc.
Debt Relief Law Florida
Debt Relievers Inc.
Debt Remedy Consultants
Debt Remedy Solutions LLC
Debt Solution Partners
Deudas Consolidates Inc.
Freedom Debt Management
Great American Credit Repair
ioudebtsolutions.com
Managed Debt Solutions
New You Credit Repair
Oasis Credit Solutions
Premier Debt Center of Boca Raton
Resolvly
Say No to the Bank
Student Debt Experts
This is 46 firms identified by Manta as debt relief companies in Boca Raton alone. A few of these might not technically be debt relief companies, but on the other hand, this list does not include a number of attorneys who are used as fronts for debt relief companies, and some companies might have been missed completely.
If these firms have 20 employees on average, roughly 1% of the population of Boca Raton works in the Debt Relief industry, and if you assume that half of the population of Boca Raton is made up of either retired people or children, then it would be 2% of the population of Boca Raton works in the debt relief industry.
While it is theoretically possible that not all debt relief companies are running a scam, there are some practices that are clearly outside of the bounds of propriety:
1. Selling debt relief by telemarketing. It is virtually impossible for debt relief telemarketers to comply with the FTC Telemarketing Rule. Most of them don't even try. If the telemarker approaches you on behalf of an attorney or law firm, understand that almost every state has rules against soliciting clients, especially paying third parties to solicit clients.
2. Nonrefundable fees. The FTC and various states have rules about when debt relief companies are allowed to take a fee. To overly simplify: the fee received must be proportional to the debt actually negotiated and the fee must only be taken after the debt was reduced.
3. The names of other companies showing up in either the servicing of accounts or the processing of accounts.
4. Any involvement of an attorney in the mass settlement of debts except for the practice of bankruptcy law.
5. Any talk of "natural law" or "sovereign immunity".
I could go on and on. Investigate a company before you hire them. Ask for references. Just don't give one a pile of money. If you are in a contract with a debt relief company and you want to know if you have to keep paying on the contract or if maybe you can get your money back, contact a consumer attorney in your area through the National Association of Consumer Advocates' "Find an Attorney" page.
Boca Raton Florida has an estimated population of around 92,000 people. Look at all the "debt relief" companies that came up on a simple search at manta.com.
1st National Credit Services Corporation
Absolute Debt Solution
Accelerated Debt Consolidation
Acci Inc.
Advanced Credit Solutions Inc.
American Consolidated Debt
American Corporate Turnaround, Inc.
American Debt
American Debt Negotiators
American Debt Settlement Solutions, Inc.
Amerifinancial Solutions, LLC
A Plus Financial Solutions
Bmv Corporation
Capital Debt Relief
Clear Debt
Consumer Credit Counseling Service
Consumer Credit Counseling Service of South Florida
Consumer Debt Counselor Group
Consumer Debt Counselor Group LLC
Credicare Credit Counseling
Credit Repair
Credit Repair Doctor
Credit Restoration
Dartmouth Foundation, Inc.
Debt B Gone
Debt Franchise Inc.
Debt Management Solutions
Debtmet LLC
Debt Pro Assoc LLC
Debt Relief Group Inc.
Debt Relief Law Florida
Debt Relievers Inc.
Debt Remedy Consultants
Debt Remedy Solutions LLC
Debt Solution Partners
Deudas Consolidates Inc.
Freedom Debt Management
Great American Credit Repair
ioudebtsolutions.com
Managed Debt Solutions
New You Credit Repair
Oasis Credit Solutions
Premier Debt Center of Boca Raton
Resolvly
Say No to the Bank
Student Debt Experts
This is 46 firms identified by Manta as debt relief companies in Boca Raton alone. A few of these might not technically be debt relief companies, but on the other hand, this list does not include a number of attorneys who are used as fronts for debt relief companies, and some companies might have been missed completely.
If these firms have 20 employees on average, roughly 1% of the population of Boca Raton works in the Debt Relief industry, and if you assume that half of the population of Boca Raton is made up of either retired people or children, then it would be 2% of the population of Boca Raton works in the debt relief industry.
While it is theoretically possible that not all debt relief companies are running a scam, there are some practices that are clearly outside of the bounds of propriety:
1. Selling debt relief by telemarketing. It is virtually impossible for debt relief telemarketers to comply with the FTC Telemarketing Rule. Most of them don't even try. If the telemarker approaches you on behalf of an attorney or law firm, understand that almost every state has rules against soliciting clients, especially paying third parties to solicit clients.
2. Nonrefundable fees. The FTC and various states have rules about when debt relief companies are allowed to take a fee. To overly simplify: the fee received must be proportional to the debt actually negotiated and the fee must only be taken after the debt was reduced.
3. The names of other companies showing up in either the servicing of accounts or the processing of accounts.
4. Any involvement of an attorney in the mass settlement of debts except for the practice of bankruptcy law.
5. Any talk of "natural law" or "sovereign immunity".
I could go on and on. Investigate a company before you hire them. Ask for references. Just don't give one a pile of money. If you are in a contract with a debt relief company and you want to know if you have to keep paying on the contract or if maybe you can get your money back, contact a consumer attorney in your area through the National Association of Consumer Advocates' "Find an Attorney" page.
Tuesday, February 28, 2017
If you have a Home Alarm System Read This:
If you have a home alarm system that is monitored through a cell-phone system, you may not be getting the monitoring that you are paying for. You could be paying money for nothing and leaving your home unprotected at the same time. The reason is that your system likely runs on a discontinued cellular network standard called "2g". This is an issue that alarm companies have known about since at least 2015.
Apparently, up to 90% of home alarm systems installed before 2015 that used cell service were based on "2g" technology. In December 2016, some cellular telephone companies, including AT&T largely discontinued "2g" service to monitoring companies. In the summer of 2016, ADT reported that it sent a letter out to its customers offering to convert their system to 3g/4g cell capability at no charge, but it has been brought to our attention that not all customers received notice. Many customers either switched monitoring companies or ADT assigned monitoring contracts to third party companies.
The bottom line is that if you have an older, "2g" cell phone modem in your alarm system, and you haven't upgraded it, there is a strong possibility that your alarm system has not been monitored since December 2016. I think that companies holding monitoring contracts should be held to a pro-active standard, and if they are still collecting monitoring money from customers who haven't upgraded, they need to refund the money to the customers.
If that weren't bad enough, there are reports that the 2g-3g changeover has resulted in a new scam of companies posing as the original monitoring company calling customers and promising free upgrades, but instead signing the customer up for long-term monitoring contracts at high rates. Senior citizens are often targeted by home security scammers.
If you have an issue relating to the changeover to 3g-4g, please send me an email to hoferlawindy at gmail.com. There should be a contact link at the top of the page.
Apparently, up to 90% of home alarm systems installed before 2015 that used cell service were based on "2g" technology. In December 2016, some cellular telephone companies, including AT&T largely discontinued "2g" service to monitoring companies. In the summer of 2016, ADT reported that it sent a letter out to its customers offering to convert their system to 3g/4g cell capability at no charge, but it has been brought to our attention that not all customers received notice. Many customers either switched monitoring companies or ADT assigned monitoring contracts to third party companies.
The bottom line is that if you have an older, "2g" cell phone modem in your alarm system, and you haven't upgraded it, there is a strong possibility that your alarm system has not been monitored since December 2016. I think that companies holding monitoring contracts should be held to a pro-active standard, and if they are still collecting monitoring money from customers who haven't upgraded, they need to refund the money to the customers.
If that weren't bad enough, there are reports that the 2g-3g changeover has resulted in a new scam of companies posing as the original monitoring company calling customers and promising free upgrades, but instead signing the customer up for long-term monitoring contracts at high rates. Senior citizens are often targeted by home security scammers.
If you have an issue relating to the changeover to 3g-4g, please send me an email to hoferlawindy at gmail.com. There should be a contact link at the top of the page.
Wednesday, February 22, 2017
Letter to the Editor Supporting the CFPB and the Dodd Frank Act
Senator Ted Cruz proposed legislation that would dismantle the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau. Donald Trump has stated publicly that he wants to repeal the majority of the Dodd Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act. Dear consumers, the CFPB and the Dodd Frank Act are essential at keeping the robber barons from stealing you blind. The current administration is so hostile to consumer interests that two NACA attorneys that I know are refusing to represent any consumer who voted for Donald Trump. I'm not going that far, but I hope that whether you voted for Donald Trump or not, you will contact your congressional representative. Finding your representative is easy, just go to www.whoismyrepresentative.com
I can't believe that the votor mandate for the people that were voted in in November was a mandate to roll back consumer protections to the bad old days.
Anyway, I drafted a letter to the editor of the Indianapolis Star, my hometown newspaper, and I am publishing it here whether or not it gets published in the paper. and it is published below.
Save the CFPB and The Dodd Frank Act
Most Americans have never heard of the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, or even its initials, CFPB; but if you ask most Americans if they think the government should have an agency that protects people from financial frauds and rip-offs, safeguards their savings and makes sure the banking system is sound, most people would say “absolutely yes”. That’s exactly what the CFPB does. Even though most Americans approve of the CFPB’s mission, and the CFPB has been successful in accomplishing that mission, the new Congress and the Trump Administration are trying to fast-track legislation to eliminate the CPFB. I want to tell you why you shouldn’t let that happen.
The CFPB wasn’t even formed until 2010, but in its first five years, the CFPB has recovered $11.7 billion dollars for consumers. Basted on its annual budget of around $600 million, the CFPB has paid for itself roughly four times over just in its recoveries for consumers. The CFPB does a lot more than just recover cash for consumers. It sets the standards for fair dealing in the financial marketplace. The CFPB has instituted new rules that eliminated some of the most unfair practices in the credit card industry. The CFPB has a department that is dedicated to eliminating scams targeting service members. The CFPB has targeted predatory practices involving payday loans and student loans. The CFPB has handled more than one million consumer complaints involving financial institutions.
As a consumer advocate attorney representing homeowners in mortgage foreclosure cases, I saw first-hand the difference in the marketplace before and after the CFPB. In the wild 90s through the Great Recession in 2008, the subprime mortgage market was like Dodge City. Consumers were being ripped off by predatory loans that were shockingly unfair but in some cases completely legal. These predatory loans and the questionable investment products that supported them crashed our economy in 2008. This was a crash caused, not by excessive regulation, but by too much greed and too little regulation. The Dodd Frank Act and the CFPB put new standards in place that eliminated the worst abuses in the mortgage market, and provided a framework for lenders to modify mortgages to keep consumers in their homes. Initially the lenders fought these modifications, but eventually the lenders realized that even they benefited by fair modifications that turned nonperforming loans into performing loans and reversed a downturn in home values that threatened all their loans.
Consumers don’t even see what could be the CFPB’s most important function, and that is supervising financial institutions, making sure they have enough capital to weather a market downturn so the institutions won’t have to be bailed out by the federal government down the road.
Despite the CFPB’s achievements, this agency has been targeted for elimination by the Trump administration. This is nothing but a naked ploy by the financial crooks to get rid of the cop on the beat. To justify their actions, the supporters claim the financial industry cannot thrive under the CFPB and Dodd Frank Act. This is a lie. Even under the CFPB, bank profits are at or near record highs. Commercial and consumer lending is thriving.
I urge all who read this to contact your senators and representative and tell them to vote the way of the public and not the way of the lobbyists, and vote to save the CFPB and the Dodd Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act.
Steven Hofer
Indiana State Chairperson
National Association of Consumer Advocates
I can't believe that the votor mandate for the people that were voted in in November was a mandate to roll back consumer protections to the bad old days.
Anyway, I drafted a letter to the editor of the Indianapolis Star, my hometown newspaper, and I am publishing it here whether or not it gets published in the paper. and it is published below.
Save the CFPB and The Dodd Frank Act
Most Americans have never heard of the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, or even its initials, CFPB; but if you ask most Americans if they think the government should have an agency that protects people from financial frauds and rip-offs, safeguards their savings and makes sure the banking system is sound, most people would say “absolutely yes”. That’s exactly what the CFPB does. Even though most Americans approve of the CFPB’s mission, and the CFPB has been successful in accomplishing that mission, the new Congress and the Trump Administration are trying to fast-track legislation to eliminate the CPFB. I want to tell you why you shouldn’t let that happen.
The CFPB wasn’t even formed until 2010, but in its first five years, the CFPB has recovered $11.7 billion dollars for consumers. Basted on its annual budget of around $600 million, the CFPB has paid for itself roughly four times over just in its recoveries for consumers. The CFPB does a lot more than just recover cash for consumers. It sets the standards for fair dealing in the financial marketplace. The CFPB has instituted new rules that eliminated some of the most unfair practices in the credit card industry. The CFPB has a department that is dedicated to eliminating scams targeting service members. The CFPB has targeted predatory practices involving payday loans and student loans. The CFPB has handled more than one million consumer complaints involving financial institutions.
As a consumer advocate attorney representing homeowners in mortgage foreclosure cases, I saw first-hand the difference in the marketplace before and after the CFPB. In the wild 90s through the Great Recession in 2008, the subprime mortgage market was like Dodge City. Consumers were being ripped off by predatory loans that were shockingly unfair but in some cases completely legal. These predatory loans and the questionable investment products that supported them crashed our economy in 2008. This was a crash caused, not by excessive regulation, but by too much greed and too little regulation. The Dodd Frank Act and the CFPB put new standards in place that eliminated the worst abuses in the mortgage market, and provided a framework for lenders to modify mortgages to keep consumers in their homes. Initially the lenders fought these modifications, but eventually the lenders realized that even they benefited by fair modifications that turned nonperforming loans into performing loans and reversed a downturn in home values that threatened all their loans.
Consumers don’t even see what could be the CFPB’s most important function, and that is supervising financial institutions, making sure they have enough capital to weather a market downturn so the institutions won’t have to be bailed out by the federal government down the road.
Despite the CFPB’s achievements, this agency has been targeted for elimination by the Trump administration. This is nothing but a naked ploy by the financial crooks to get rid of the cop on the beat. To justify their actions, the supporters claim the financial industry cannot thrive under the CFPB and Dodd Frank Act. This is a lie. Even under the CFPB, bank profits are at or near record highs. Commercial and consumer lending is thriving.
I urge all who read this to contact your senators and representative and tell them to vote the way of the public and not the way of the lobbyists, and vote to save the CFPB and the Dodd Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act.
Steven Hofer
Indiana State Chairperson
National Association of Consumer Advocates
Friday, February 10, 2017
Have You Been Sued by LVNV Funding, LLC in Indiana
Have you been sued by LVNV Funding, LLC, This company buys a lot of old debt, and they file a lot of lawsuits. I am looking into some issues that I've noticed in LVNV's documentation If you have been sued by them in Indiana, please call me at 317-662-4529.
Old Spice Deodorant - Is Old Spice Deodorant Safe to Use?
This morning I got up, and I put on Old Spice deodorant. This afternoon I handled an intake from a person who claimed fairly serious injuries relating to Old Spice deodorant. I wondered whether this is an isolated occurrance, so I googled "old-spice deodorant (injured or injuries) and came up with 1.47 million hits.
Proctor and Gamble, makers of Old Spice, maintain their deodorant is seafe, and the injuries claimed are not chemical burns, they are imune reactions unique to the individuals claiming the injury - freak occurances in other words.
In my mind, it doesn't matter if the injuries are chemical burns or not. If there are enough of them, even if they are the product of allergic reactions, the product is not reasonably safe. If you are injured by Old Spice or any other product, you should save the prroduct and report the injury both to the manufacturer and the Food and Drug Administration. DO NOT GIVE THE PRODUCT BACK TO THE MANUFACTURER. At most give them a small sample to test.
If you have injuries that require medical treatment, you should consider contacting an attorney who handles personal injury cases. If you are in Indiana, I would like to hear from you, call me at 317-662-4529.
There are various law firms that are advertising for these cases, and at least one class action has been filed. I suggest anyone affected find a LOCAL attorney to represent you. Your local attorney can team up with other attorneys to take on P&G on more equal terms. If you rely on a national law firm only, it is easy to fall between the cracks and not get the kind of individual attention that you might expect.
I have nothing to do with the production of the video below that I found on Youtube.
Proctor and Gamble, makers of Old Spice, maintain their deodorant is seafe, and the injuries claimed are not chemical burns, they are imune reactions unique to the individuals claiming the injury - freak occurances in other words.
In my mind, it doesn't matter if the injuries are chemical burns or not. If there are enough of them, even if they are the product of allergic reactions, the product is not reasonably safe. If you are injured by Old Spice or any other product, you should save the prroduct and report the injury both to the manufacturer and the Food and Drug Administration. DO NOT GIVE THE PRODUCT BACK TO THE MANUFACTURER. At most give them a small sample to test.
If you have injuries that require medical treatment, you should consider contacting an attorney who handles personal injury cases. If you are in Indiana, I would like to hear from you, call me at 317-662-4529.
There are various law firms that are advertising for these cases, and at least one class action has been filed. I suggest anyone affected find a LOCAL attorney to represent you. Your local attorney can team up with other attorneys to take on P&G on more equal terms. If you rely on a national law firm only, it is easy to fall between the cracks and not get the kind of individual attention that you might expect.
I have nothing to do with the production of the video below that I found on Youtube.
Wednesday, February 1, 2017
Is Credit One Bank on your credit report? Have they been calling you?
We are investigating practices by Credit One Bank relating to their telemarketing (robocalls) and their credit reporting and possibly accessing the credit information of those who do not have accounts with them. If you have a credit report with Credit One on it, and you didn't have an account with them, I would love to see it and talk to you.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)