About The Consumer Law Office of Steve Hofer

Steve Hofer has been practicing consumer law in Indiana for more than 20 years. He is a former Indiana State Chairperson of the National Association of Consumer Advocates, a national organization of attorneys striving for fairness in the consumer marketplace. Contact me by phone at 317-662-4529 or via email at hoferlawindyATgmail.com. You can also leave a message through my website at www.hoferlawindy.com.

Tuesday, September 23, 2014

Beware of Pension Factoring Ripoffs

I've been a lawyer for 27 years, more than half my live.  I've handled over 100,000 intakes in that time. Recently I was approached regarding a a type of transaction that I had never seen before. It involved pension factoring and a company called Voyager Financial Group, LLC.  Voyager approaches people who need money and have an income stream from a pension fund or something similar, and they offer their services as brokers to get the person cash up front for his or her pension scheme. the pensioner pledges the income from the pension as security for the advance. It seems obvious to me that this is a loan by any other name but so far Voyager and like companies have dodged scrutiny as lenders.  Voyager has run afoul of securities commissioners in several states because Voyager does not put up its own money, it recruits investors to buy the income streams. Because this is passive income for the investor, it is a security and should be registered.

The best mainstream journalistic article that I've seen on the subject is this one from the New York Times.

In the business world, factoring is common. The most common factoring is accounts receivable. Another type of factoring involves payment in advance for structured settlement payments.  The intermediaries in these transactions can potentially rip off both the investors and the person obtaining the lump sum, a/k/a the borrowers.  The implied interest rates in these deals are quite high. From what I've seen the rates exceed the 21% maximum legal rate for mainstream lenders in most states.  It's not such a great deal for the investor, either. The pensioner can actually cut off the stream of income. I think it's arguable whether these contracts are ever legal due to lack of disclosure on the consumer side and lack of registration of the various lenders and intermediaries.

If you have a problem with a pension factoring company, or of you sold pension payments, especially if you are getting collection letters relating to the pension assignment, I am interested in hearing from you. Call me at 317-662-4529. If you are not in my area (Indiana), I will try to link you up with a NACA attorney.  

Wednesday, September 17, 2014

The FTC SUES MULTIPLE FIRMS FOR FAKE PAYDAY LOANS

What's worse than a payday loan? Not much, but one thing that is worse is a fake payday loan. The FTC has taken action against a group of firms they say bilked consumers out of tens of millions of dollars by putting through electronic funds transfer requests for payments on loans that never existed. The companies allegedly used personal information gathered by sneaky means to drain the bank accounts of  its victims.

I ran into a couple of instances of fake payday loans when I worked for UAW Legal Services. It wasn't the scam artists that troubled me the most in these cases, it was the banks who refused to follow proper procedures when customers made claims of unauthorized withdrawals.  If you find that your bank account has been tapped to pay for payday loans real or fake without authorization, I suggest that you start taking steps to close your account.  Once they have your information, they can start fake transfer requests again using multiple corporate identities.   Below are the company names listed in the FTC press release. There could be many more.

The complaint announced today was filed against: 1) CWB Services, LLC; 2) Orion Services, LLC; 3) Sand Point Capital, LLC; 4) Sandpoint, LLC; 5) Basseterre Capital, LLC (based in both Nevis and Delaware); 6) Namakan Capital, LLC; 7) Vandelier Group, LLC; 8) St. Armands Group, LLC; 9) Anasazi Group, LLC; 10) Anasazi Services, LLC; 11) Longboat Group, LLC, also doing business as (d/b/a) Cutter Group; 12) Oread Group, LLC, also d/b/a Mass Street Group; 13) Timothy A. Coppinger, individually and as a principal of one or more of the corporate defendants; and 14) Frampton T. Rowland, III, individually and as a principal of one or more of the corporate defendants.

UAW Legal Services Plans - Not Dead Yet


For many years, I was a staff attorney with UAW Legal Services Plans (UAWLSP) in Indianapolis. The legal services benefit was a casualty of the bargaining process in the last contract between the automakers and the UAW. UAWLSP stopped taking new cases at the end of 2013 and has been closing cases and phasing out operations ever since. The website at www.uawlsp.com has apparently not been updated since sometime in 2013. Unfortunately, this means that plan members have no easy way of finding out the status of their local legal services office, and they may not know what happened to their files and the attorneys who served them for many years.  The last thing that I heard is that UAWLSP will continue in at least nominal existence through at least part of 2015, but some local offices may be closed in the meantime.  If you are looking for an ex-UAW Legal Services (ex-UAWLSP) attorney, even if you are outside of my area, send me an email through my webpage at www.hoferlawindy.com, and I will either try to find your old attorney or find you a new attorney through my contacts at the National Association of Consumer Advocates.  

IF YOU ARE A FORMER UAWLSP ATTORNEY AND YOU HAVE JOINED A NEW LAW FIRM OR STARTED YOUR OWN PRACTICE, PLEASE POST A COMMENT IN THE SPACE BELOW INCLUDING YOUR NAME, OFFICE ADDRESS, PHONE, WEBSITE URL, AND ANYTHING ELSE YOU WANT THE PUBLIC TO KNOW. I will be happy to link blogs with you.  Gee, that sounds kind of dirty.

(Note to the Python folks. Don't sue me for using the picture, just tell me to take it down if it bothers you.  I've spent a lot of money on Python stuff. Be nice to me.)  

Thursday, August 21, 2014

HOFER LAW FILES OPEN RECORDS COMPLAINT AGAINST LOCAL SMALL CLAIMS COURT

Today I filed  an official Access to Public Records Act complaint against the Wayne Township Small Claims Court in Indianapolis. I don't do this lightly. Twenty years ago, I filed a complaint against a judge who was letting collection lawyer run the court, and although the judge was reprimanded, I was effectively blacklisted from all the Small Claims Courts.  I filed the complaint because I intend to continue to investigate patterns of filing collection cases in the small claims courts, and I can't afford to go to each court twice, once just to get turned down and the second time to get the information after convincing the court staff that the open records act applies.   My complaint is below.

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Consumer Law Office of Steve Hofer
3750 Guion Road, Suite 190
Indianapolis IN 46222
317-662-4LAW                                                                                                                  www.hoferlawindy.com
317-662-4529                                                                                                                                 hoferlawindy@gmail.com

                                                                                                             
August 21, 2014                                                Via Mail and Fax 317-233-3091

Luke Britt
Indiana Public Access Counselor
W470 Indiana Government Center South
402 West Washington Street
Indianapolis IN 46204

              OFFICIAL OPEN RECORDS COMPLAINT
                                              Agency: Wayne Township (Marion County) Small Claims Court
                                              5401 West Washington Street, Indianapolis IN 46241
                                              Date of Request/Agency Denied Access: August 4, 2014

Dear Counselor Britt:

I am hereby making a complaint of denied access under the Indiana Access to Public Records Act.  The agency in question is the Wayne Township Small Claims Court in Indianapolis.  On Monday, August 4, 2014, during regular business hours, between 2:30 and 3:00 PM; I went to the Wayne Township Small Claims Court for the purposes of reviewing a selection of recent cases filed by bad debt buyers.  The abuse of the court system by bad debt buyers is a matter of public concern.  For context see: The One Hundred Billion Dollar Problem in Small Claims Court: Robo-Signing and Lack of Proof, Peter A. Holland, published in Journal of Business & Technology Law, Vol. 6, p. 259, 2011 and online at http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=1875727. See also the New York Times Magazine feature story Paper Boys: Inside the Dark, Labyrinth, and Extremely Lucrative World of Consumer  Debt Collection,  Jake Halpern, http://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2014/08/15/magazine/bad-paper-debt-collector.html?_r=0. 

At the Wayne Township Court, I was allowed to use the public access terminal to identify a selection of recent cases. I copied down some case numbers, approximately 20, and asked to see the files that went with the case numbers.  The attendant said that I was not allowed to see the files, that they were not public. The only public information was the information on the terminal. I told the attendant that she is mistaken, these are public records that are readily accessed by collection attorneys on a daily basis.  On that same day I had inspected files without incident at Pike Township Small Claims Court. The attendant told me that I would have to take it up with the supervisor who was not in, and would not be available until tomorrow. She would not give me the full name of the supervisor. I offered to make a written request, but I was rebuffed. 

I believe it is the responsibility of the agency to have persons trained in compliance with the act on duty during all regular business hours regardless of the presence or absence of any given supervisor.  I believe my treatment at this court conveys an image that the court’s policy is to be friendly to debt collectors but not to persons who want to police the conduct of debt collectors.

Finally, I would have made an informal request for an opinion by the counselor if it were not for a disturbing fact that I found out later.  In the MYCASE online record system, the defendants’ names are missing from the online records of a number of collection cases filed in Wayne and Lawrence Townships after 8/11/2014.   (See enclosed documentation.) If researchers aren't even able to get defendant names from the online system; it will be impossible to uncover problems with debt collectors misusing the court system[1].

Sincerely,



Steven R. Hofer
Attorney at Law


 ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
The MYCASE documents that I attached included lawsuits filed by:

Credit Acceptance Corporation
LVNV Funding LLC
Convergence Receivables LC
Calvary SPV 1 LLC
MSW Capital LLC
Second Round LP
Credit Acceptance Corporation
NCEP, LLC
Jefferson Capital Systems, LLC
























Enclosures – Mycase records



[1] The Mycase sheets are included for illustration only. Because for this purpose the names of the defendants are irrelevant, I have partially redacted those that are included.  
  Co

Monday, August 18, 2014

New York Times - Inside the Criminial Underworld of the Debt Collection Industry

Last week's New York Times Sunday magazine had a feature story detailing the criminal underworld network behind the bottom feeder debt collection industry.  The article, by Jake Halpern,  titled Paperboys: Inside the Dark Lucrative World of Consumer Debt Collection explains how the industry uses lies and pressure to make huge profits by paying 1% of the face amount of the debt and collecting 100% through intimidation and unfair collection lawsuits.


 





When the collectors go to court, no matter how many times the debt has been assigned, the collector maintains that the debt is absolutely legitimate and absolutely owned by the agency collecting it.  This is often a fallacy.   The debts are sometimes sold to multiple parties, each trying to collect; and sometimes unauthorized people get a hold of the accounts list and start outlaw collection.  That's why individuals and the courts must insist on strict accounting for proceeds and ownership of the accounts.   They aren't doing it right now.

Friday, August 15, 2014

John Oliver Takes on the Payday Loan Industry



John Oliver Takes On the Payday Loan Industry


Sometimes it takes somebody from somewhere else to really see how much you are messing up.  John Oliver takes the time to expose the myths and lies in the payday loan industry.  Language Alert.