About The Consumer Law Office of Steve Hofer

Steve Hofer has been practicing consumer law in Indiana for more than 20 years. He is a former Indiana State Chairperson of the National Association of Consumer Advocates, a national organization of attorneys striving for fairness in the consumer marketplace. Contact me by phone at 317-662-4529 or via email at hoferlawindyATgmail.com. You can also leave a message through my website at www.hoferlawindy.com.

Thursday, July 18, 2019

Business Plaintiffs received Big Fraud Verdict Against Lexington Law.

A couple of businesses that said they were spammed by dispute letters purporting to be from consumers but really from Lexington Law received a jury verdict on a claim of fraud according to this article at InsideArm.com.

This is a good time to remind people that a credit repair agency can't do anything you can't do for yourself.  Credit bureaus and creditors have to fully process legitimate dispute letters, but they don't have to give the same weight to mass generated letters not backed by a good faith dispute.  If you want your dispute considered, you should write the letter yourself and explain why you dispute the item. 

I don't like these companies because the spam disputes cause companies to disregard good faith dispute letters, and that makes it harder for consumers with real disputes to get them addressed.

Thursday, July 11, 2019

200,000 2017-2019 Chrysler Pacificas Recalled for Stalling Issues

200,000 Chrysler Pacifica owners should be receiving recall notices about now for a recall of 200,000 Pacificas equipped with automatic stop/start systems.  The recall is allegedly to fix a wiring issue that can cause stalling. Owners of Pacifica will be excused if they don't believe this will fix the stalling issues they have been experiencing.

Perhaps Chrysler is confident they got it right now, because recently they announced that for 2020 they will be selling a decontented version of the Pacifica which will be badged as the Chrysler Voyager.  (Until the Plymouth brand was discontinued, the Plymouth version of the Mopar van was called the "Plymouth Voyager".)  Two and a half years after the Chrysler Pacifica was introduced the Pacifica continues to be outsold by the decade-old Dodge Grand Caravan.


Monday, July 1, 2019

Car and Driver's Long term 2018 Chrysler Pacifica Hybrid Many Warranty Repairs

I find the most interesting car magazine long-term tests are the ones where the vehicles experience major problems.  I was majorly bummed out to read Car and Driver's 40,000 mile summary of their experience with the Pacifica Hybrid minivan. I was seriously considering getting one of these as my next vehicle. Honestly, based on this report and some other sources, I think I'm going to skip this generation and see what happens the next time around.

Quoting the article about problems with this Pacifica:

While our Pacifica hybrid completed the final 10,000 miles without any major expenses, it wasn't completely drama-free. We had to replace both front anti-roll-bar end links under warranty to fix a persistent rattle from the front end. The dealership also had to replace the whole center console, due to a seized cupholder bin on the lower back side that was permanently stuck open. Luckily, this was covered under warranty, or it would've cost us $1590. These recent issues were preceded by regular logbook entries over the first 30,000 miles about disconcerting engine noises (something the dealership said was normal) and an unsettling incident where the hybrid's 16.0-kWh battery pack had to be replaced. Similarly, we experienced two instances where the battery coolant was low, but the dealer was unable to diagnose the cause either time. All of these problems were covered under warranty, which is great, but it certainly made editors think twice about taking what is otherwise a great road-trip car on road trips, not to mention gave us doubts about the minivan's long-term reliability.

Sunday, June 30, 2019

Chase is Reinstating Forced Arbitration on Credit Cards - How to Opt Out

Chase Bank is in the process of reinstating forced arbitration upon its most of its credit card holders.  Chase had abandoned forced arbitration for a while in a settlement with the Obama administration over unfair practices in 2009.  Thanks to an almost complete takeover of the CFPB by lender interests under the Trump administration, Chase is emboldened to reinstate mandatory arbitration even though a comprehensive investigation by the pre-Trump CFPB found that it is unfair to consumers.

Chase is claiming that the arbitration is optional by giving consumers the ability to opt out.  The opt-out process is a bit of a pain in the ass but not crazy-hard.  The cardholder must  mail chase a signed, written opt-out notice. That notice must be received by Chase by the date set in the Chase notice to the cardholder. In the Yahoo post above, the date is given as August 9, 2019. In the notices my family received, it was August 23, 2019.

 I am printing below a version of the opt-out letter that we sent.  There is not phone, email or web opt out procedure.  Note, that there is some chance the opt-out address that you rae given might be different, but if it is the same, you can just cut and paste this notice, add your name and card number, and mail it in.

-------


Cardholder’s Name and address

Chase
P.0 Box 15298
Wilmington DE 19850-5298

Notice of Rejection of Arbitration Provision
Account Number

I hereby notify you that I am opting out of the arbitration provision.


Cardholder Signature

------


You don't have to mail it certified mail, but you should have some proof you mailed it.  For example, give it to somebody else to mail, and have them make a note in their calendar that they mailed it.  That will raise a presumption of proof of delivery.

Finally, I want to give kudos to AARP.  They negotiated terms with Chase that removes the mandatory arbitration. If you have a Chase affilliate card with any other entity (especially universities and trade associations) you should write to that entity and advise them that if AARP can negotiate the arbtration term, they should as well.

https://finance.yahoo.com/news/chase-forced-arbitration-credit-cards-sapphire-192909115.html


Friday, June 21, 2019

Auto Zone accused of 5 Million hazardous waste violations in in California alone - oh, and Data Privacy Breaches Too

Every time I go to an auto parts store - any auto parts store, there's always some bozo pouring nasty stuff into his car, and tossing the container out in the parking lot.  Sometimes there are people with oil leaks, putting in oil, and half of it goes straight onto the pavement.  Therefore, it was not a surprise, when the state of California accused Auto Zone of up to 5 million hazardous waste violations, and it didn't surprise me when Auto Zone agreed to pay $11 million in a consent decree.   From the TTAC.com article above:

From the California Attorney General’s Office:
District Attorneys’ offices throughout California conducted 56 inspections of dumpster bins at 49 separate AutoZone facilities. These investigations found numerous instances of unlawful disposal of hazardous waste including batteries, aerosol cans, electronic devices, and hundreds of discarded bottles and other receptacles containing automotive fluids and other regulated hazardous waste. These investigative efforts revealed that AutoZone allowed its customers to deposit hazardous automotive fluids and other waste items into regular trash containers in AutoZone stores’ parking lots throughout California. AutoZone facilities in 45 counties in California were found by the prosecuting offices to have committed these environmental violations. It is estimated that AutoZone illegally disposed of over five million hazardous waste items in California.
AutoZone also violated laws protecting vulnerable confidential consumer information by unlawfully disposing of customer records without having rendered personal information unreadable.

 The company is getting off easy.

The thing is, Auto Zone isn't necessarily better or worse in this respect than any other auto parts store all over the country.  The whole industry deserves more scrutiny. General retailers selling automotive and household chemicals need more scrutiny as well. I personally believe that there is a law saying every company that sells motor oil must accept used motor-oil for recycling in the same quantity they sell.  Maybe the same should go for other chemicals as well.

Monday, June 17, 2019

How about that? I didn't even pay them anything

I was rated one of the 3 Best Consumer Protection Lawyers in Indianapolis by threebestrated.com.  Congratulations to my friends,  Syed Ali Saeed and Ryan Frasher, who share the top three with me.  All three of us are members of the National Association of Consumer Advocates (NACA).  We have attended conferences together, presented at conferences together, done pro-bono togetherThough to a certain extent we are competitors, as a practical matter, we are more colleagues. We have known each other for years, and spread knowledge for the benefit of all.  I am honored by being included in a list with Ali and Ryan.  


Historically, I haven't put a lot of credence in ratings like this.  Some "best lawyers" type publications you basically buy your way in.  In don't know anything about the people that publish this list.  I didn't pay them anything.  Nevertheles, I got a kick out of seeing this.  


Thursday, June 13, 2019

Defenders: the Real "Hole in the Wall Gang?"

From WBBM-Chicago



If you get scammed by a home contractor, including security contractor, you should make a complaint with your state attorney general and BBB immediately.  You should also do a Google search to see if there is a pattern and practice.