About The Consumer Law Office of Steve Hofer

Steve Hofer has been practicing consumer law in Indiana for more than 20 years. He is a former Indiana State Chairperson of the National Association of Consumer Advocates, a national organization of attorneys striving for fairness in the consumer marketplace. Contact me by phone at 317-662-4529 or via email at hoferlawindyATgmail.com. You can also leave a message through my website at www.hoferlawindy.com.

Tuesday, June 9, 2020

Body Attachments for Contempt of Court in Indiana, Some Welcome Changes

For years, Indiana has been a center for injustice regarding the issuance of body attachments for unpaid civil judgments.  A body attachment is basically an arrest. Technically, it is not for failure to pay the judgment, rather, it is for contempt of court for failing to attend a proceeding supplemental to judgment to give information to the plaintiff for purposes of collecting the judgment. That being said there are a number of legitimate reasons why a person might not attend a proceeding supplemental. The most common is they never know about the proceeding supplemental in the first place. Other reasons might be lack of child care, lack of transportation, inability to read and understand the legal pleadings, illness or general incompetence. 

Both federal and state law prohibits imprisonment for debt. Section 22 of the Indiana Constitution provides as follows:

Section 22. Debts--Imprisonment exemption

Section 22. The privilege of the debtor to enjoy the necessary comforts of life, shall be recognized by wholesome laws, exempting a reasonable amount of property from seizure or sale, for the payment of any debt or liability hereafter contracted: and there shall be no imprisonment for debt, except in case of fraud.

For at least as long as I've been an attorney, 33 years and counting, courts have issued body attachments in the form of a bench warrant, an arrest warrant. . It has worked differently in different counties, but if a law enforcement officer seizes the person, the law enforcement officer is supposed to take the person to the court, for questioning about why the person did not attend the proceeding supplemental.  On many occasions the person was seized and the court was not in session, so the person had to stay in jail over a weekend, sometimes an extended holiday weekend. 

In recent years there has been some attention in the press to the issue of poor people spending time in jail because they can't pay civil judgments, and it looks like it is finally starting to pay dividends in court rules. Today I was reading Delaware County's local rules in preparation for a case, and I found out that they recently adopted rules greatly reducing the power to issue a bench warrant on a civil judgment.  Essentially the defendant has to prove actual notice and if the warrant is issued, it must be done during court hours and the defendant is taken directly to the court. 

If you are subjected to a body attachment relating to a civil judgment in Indiana, we will talk to you and look into your claim at no charge.  Often plaintiffs and their attorneys make mistakes in the process, and these mistakes could give you the opportunity to collect damages in a lawsuit.  Please call us at 317-662-4529 if you have any questions.  

Monday, June 8, 2020

Lenovo Flex-14 screen flickeringI

Late last year my main Lenovo laptop had to go in the shop. To get me by while it was out of service I bought a smaller, lighter, cheaper computer, a Lenovo Flex-14 "2 in 1". It was under $550, and I've generally been happy with it, but it has an occasional screen flickering. The screen will momentarily go black.  In my family, we have had Dell, Samsung, Asus and Lenovo Computers knocked out over screen issues, so I googled to see if this was a big problem with the Flex 14, and googling "Flex 14" and "flickering" yields 403,000 hits. 

Based on the hassles of backing up, packaging and shipping my other Lenovo machine twice for warranty repair, right now I don't think the problem is sufficiently bad enough to send back my computer.  I'm keeping an eye on it.

I don't have an intention of filing a lawsuit against Lenovo or even taking on one as a lawyer. To assist folks that might need to file one, I found this lawsuit against Lenovo for a claimed screen defect in the Flex 5 from 2017.  Here is the link.  https://www.classaction.org/media/gisairo-v-lenovo-united-states-inc.pdf.  This isn't my case. I have nothing to do with it.  For more information, contact the lawyer on the complaint. 

(For the Apple fanboys out there. We have had a number of Macbook Pros and Macbook Airs over the years, and most of our problems with those machines have been limited to bad external power supplies and cords to the power supplies.  Well, that and a Macbook Pro 13 would cost about three times what I paid for the Lenovo Flex 14.)

Monday, May 18, 2020

Chapter 5 Bankruptcy may be just the lifeline that troubled small businesses need.

Since I don't practice bankruptcy law, I am just now learning about the new Chapter 5 bankruptcy provision that went into effect February 2020.  Subchapter 5 is intended to be a simplified and less-costly alternative to a Chapter 11 reorganization. 

Chapter 5 is much like a Chapter 11, but there is no creditors committee. Effectively, it is a cram-down like Chapter 13. 

I still have to learn about how personal guarantees of business debt are handled because most of my small-business debt defense clients signed personal guarantees of the business's debt.  If creditors are allowed to bring action against the guarantors while the bankruptcy is pending it may be of little use.  We'll see. 

Here is a link to a bankruptcy law firm's explanation of Chapter 5. I am not associated with this firm, and I can't guarantee the accuracy of the. information given. Anyone interested in Chapter 5 should verify all information before acting upon it. 

https://rcbizjournal.com/2020/03/23/new-bankruptcy-law-could-be-a-blessing-in-upcoming-economic-blizzard/

Tuesday, May 12, 2020

Fears of "Death Trains" may support surprisingly robust COVID-19 car sales

There is speculaton that at least in some areas new and used car sales may be surprisingly robust even with business shutdowns and high unemployment due to the corona virus.  I totally get why people might get concerned commuting by train or bus before there is a vaccination for COVID-19. 

https://www.thetruthaboutcars.com/2020/05/death-train-vs-safe-car-sales-hypothesis-gains-new-evidence/

Tuesday, April 14, 2020

CARES ACT - suspends 10% penalty on retirement account withdrawals up to $100,000

The CARES Act, which was adopted in response to the Corona Virus/Covid-19 crises includes some important provisions regarding your protected retirement accounts.  Most people can withdraw up to $100,000 from the accounts without a penalty, and with an extended time to pay taxes that are due on the money. This should come in handy for some of our clients who are paying settlements on floorplan defense cases. 

If you are a senior and are lucky enough not to need a distribution from your account, the minimum distribution requirement is also suspended. This should help you form having to sell stocks at a crisis-level low point. 

https://www.nerdwallet.com/blog/investing/cashing-out-401k-covid-19/

Monday, March 30, 2020

You can't run a national economy with half of your workers stuck at home and not producing - OR CAN YOU?

Here we are about a month into the recognized part of the COVID-19 pandemic in the United States, and we are looking at at least a month and a half of "social distancing", and ironically, the more successful we are at social distancing, the longer the economic disruptions will last before there is "herd immunity."  We are only about two weeks into the mandatory closure of schools and businesses, and people are justifiably worried that the lack of people working and generating income will cause an economic catastrophe.

The fundamental thing that most of us get intuitively is that with half of us not making money, and not spending, how do you keep the entire economy from falling down like a house of cards.  Can you run the United States economy with one hand tied behind its back?  I argue that yes, you can, and yes we have already done it. We did it for four years during World War II. 

In World War II, we had full employment, but half our economic output was going into the war effort. We were producing at maximum volume, and yet, as far as our domestic economy is concerned, half of that production did nothing to benefit the domestic economy.  What if we pretended for the sake of economic planning, that all those people staying home because of social distancing were simply producing weapons that we weren't using, or they were part of our expeditionary force, which happened to not be fighting? 

The economy survived, and to a certain degree thrived because people were bringing in wages.  Those wages were paid directly or indirectly by the government. The government paid for these wages by raising taxes, selling war bonds, and deficit spending.  We also had rationing of certain items and price controls. 

There was nothing inherently wrong in the 2 trillion dollar emergency spending package that Congress passed in its first attempt at addressing this crisis; but what has to be done is to plan an economy over the next year and a half that looks a lot like the economy we had in World War II, but the difference will be we won't actually produce weapons we don't need.  We will, however, produce on an emergency basis all of the things that we find we do need, and if the excess labor is available, we build stored value from that labor in the form of long term public works progress which turns our current expense into long-term assets. 

There are some signs that some countries get this concept. Canada is planning on paying its citizens a stipend of $2,000/month, for example.  We have to get over the mental hump that not only is this possible, that it is sustainable over the likely course of this pandemic.  I think there is not better way to get people over this hump than to point out that not only can it be done, we've done it before, right here in the United States. 

Sunday, March 22, 2020

Nextgear, Automotive Finance Corporation and the Covid-19 Pandemic

Attorney Keith Hagan and I have been defending dealers from suits by Nextgear for over two years. Nextgear has been filing about 1,000 suits per year in Hamilton County, Indiana, and that's in good economic times.  Automotive Finance Corporation (AFC) has been filing quite a few less than Nextgear in Marion County, Indiana.

We have generally been successful in cutting deals with Nextgear when our clients have enough assets or cash flow to make a serious offer.  AFC has been a tougher nut, but we have completed deals with them too. 

With the COVID-19 shutdowns, we are living in a different world now, but I'm not sure Nextgear has gotten the Memo. Nextgear is continuing to file lawsuits as if everything is normal.  Everything is not normal.  Independent dealers are looking at 3 months or more with virtually no revenue. Even thoughs who have left the business and are trying to make a new life find that bringing home a living income will be tough. 

I predict that the vast majority of the dealers and guarantors that Nextgear sues over the next 6 months, will ultimately just file bankruptcy.  We will still take cases from dealers who want our services (and we lowered our fees), but I will urge them not to settle if it means taking food off their table. 

If Nextgear wants to keep its customer base, it should suspend floorplan fees and curtailment requirements immediately. Otherwise, instead of 1,000 dealers to sue next year, they will have at least 10,000, or half their customers. 

If there is any good news for the folks who are sued by Nextgear, if after they get a judgment against you you eventually pick yourself up and turn around your financial life and start making a good income, it is possible to negotiate with Nextgear to get a discount on the judgment owed. We can help you with this.  As part of the deal, we can negotiate issues relating to the KO book.

I will update this post later, but I wanted to get something down to let people know that if they feel trapped by their floorplan lender, in the wake of the corona virus crisis, they aren't alone, and the system will have to adapt to make it possible to move forward.