A blog covering legal topics and whatever I feel like posting. Some posts on this page could be considered to be attorney advertisements.
About The Consumer Law Office of Steve Hofer
Steve Hofer has been practicing consumer law in Indiana for more than 20 years. He is a former Indiana State Chairperson of the National Association of Consumer Advocates, a national organization of attorneys striving for fairness in the consumer marketplace. Contact me by phone at 317-662-4529 or via email at hoferlawindyATgmail.com. You can also leave a message through my website at www.hoferlawindy.com.
Thursday, November 15, 2018
Total Resource Auctions and Nextgear Repos
I talk to a lot of dealers who are shocked to find out how little Nextgear sells their cars for after the cars are repossessed by Nextgear. I have had dealers tell me that Nextgear waits until the end of the auction to sell the Nextgear repos - after the majority of the bidders have gone home. Then there is another possibility. Mannheim Auctions has a separate division, "Total Resource Auctions" that according to its website specializes in nondrivable and salvage vehicles. If drivable repossessed vehicles are sold there, it seems a good case could be made that the sale is not commerically reasonable under the Uniform Commercial Code. https://publish.manheim.com/en/services/unique-vehicles/salvage.html
Thursday, November 1, 2018
Lifeway Credit Union and contracts from The College Network - Looking to set up group action
I have a client who is looking to join up with other former students/customers of The College Network for defensive and offensive action against Lifeway Credit Union. This includes looking at the company's credit reporting practices. This may be a class action, but more likely would be a multiple plaintiff non-class action, or even coordinated offensive/defensive actions. If you are paying on a Lifeway Credit Union College Network debt and think you should be able to stop, or if you stopped and are facing collection actions or bad credit reporting, please contact me at 317-662-4529 or hoferlawindyATgmail.com. (of course substitute the "@" symbol for "at" in the email address above. If you email me, please put "college network" or "Lifeway Credit Union" in the text of your email. Thanks. Steve Hofer
Monday, September 17, 2018
Indiana Attorney General Sues Two Car Dealers
The office of Indiana Attorney General Curtis Hill (I say office of, because A.G. Hill seems to be spending more time running from his scandals than running the office) filed an action against two car dealers.
According to the Indianapolis Star:
The lawsuit alleges cars sold with incorrect odometers and vehicles that were certified as rebuilt salvage vehicles under fraudlent certifications of inspection.
The lawsuit alleges that the Wheels of Fortune Dealership, which didn't have a license, and whose owner couldn't get a license, illegally sold cars piggy-backing on the license of another dealer, BWI Equipment, I
If you bought a vehicle on credit from Wheels of Fortune, LLC, Southpoint Motors, LLC Mid America Auto Remarketing, Or BWI Equipment, Inc. you MIGHT have legal grounds to get out of your loan and make your lender buy back the vehicle.
If you end up with a bad vehicle that you paid cash for, you may have to rely on whatever relief the attorney general can get because it is unlikely that the individuals behind these operations left enough money in the business to pay claims. consum
There's are lessons to be learned her by everybody. for dealers - don't let anybody else use your license, period.
For consumers:always get an independent inspection of the used vehicles you buy. Make sure you look for signs of a rebuilt wreck. Make sure you look for signs that the mileage on the vehicle might be inconsistent with the wear on the vehicle. You can get a Carfax, but they don't always tell you what you need to know.
According to the Indianapolis Star:
The civil suit, according to a news release, takes aim at Jerramy Johnson and Jeffrey Presnell, who owned and operated three southside businesses: Wheels of Fortune LLC, Southpointe Motorcars LLC and Mid America Auto Remarketing.
The men have been accused of misrepresenting mileage on motor vehicles, failing to deliver titles and charging inappropriate fees, according to the complaint. The lawsuit seeks restitution for affected consumers, many of whom are listed in the complaint, and civil penalties.
The lawsuit alleges cars sold with incorrect odometers and vehicles that were certified as rebuilt salvage vehicles under fraudlent certifications of inspection.
The lawsuit alleges that the Wheels of Fortune Dealership, which didn't have a license, and whose owner couldn't get a license, illegally sold cars piggy-backing on the license of another dealer, BWI Equipment, I
If you bought a vehicle on credit from Wheels of Fortune, LLC, Southpoint Motors, LLC Mid America Auto Remarketing, Or BWI Equipment, Inc. you MIGHT have legal grounds to get out of your loan and make your lender buy back the vehicle.
If you end up with a bad vehicle that you paid cash for, you may have to rely on whatever relief the attorney general can get because it is unlikely that the individuals behind these operations left enough money in the business to pay claims. consum
There's are lessons to be learned her by everybody. for dealers - don't let anybody else use your license, period.
For consumers:always get an independent inspection of the used vehicles you buy. Make sure you look for signs of a rebuilt wreck. Make sure you look for signs that the mileage on the vehicle might be inconsistent with the wear on the vehicle. You can get a Carfax, but they don't always tell you what you need to know.
Another Hurricane - Another Rash of Dealer Floorplan Lawsuits?
As I write this, Hurricane Florence just hit North Carolina and South Carolina. Based on what we saw with Hurricane Harvey last year, we can expect that a lot of car dealers will be especially hard-hit.
We had a number of car dealers from Houston to Louisiana hire us to defend dealer floorplan lawsuits, mostly by Nextgear. These dealers were, for the most part, established businesses that couldn't keep current on the fees and curtailments that they were being charged by their floorplan lenders.
If you find yourself with large storm losses, I suggest that you first talk to a peer dealer who faced a similar position but worked through it.
Talk to your accountant, talk to your insurance representative, talk to FEMA. Don't expect a lot of understanding from your floorplanner. Look at the possibility of getting an SBA loan to cover your floorplan debt.
If you get sued by your floorplan lender in Indiana, call us at 317-662-4529. The worst thing you can do is let the floorplan company get a default judgment on a lawsuit.
(Video from ABC News via youtube.com)
We had a number of car dealers from Houston to Louisiana hire us to defend dealer floorplan lawsuits, mostly by Nextgear. These dealers were, for the most part, established businesses that couldn't keep current on the fees and curtailments that they were being charged by their floorplan lenders.
If you find yourself with large storm losses, I suggest that you first talk to a peer dealer who faced a similar position but worked through it.
Talk to your accountant, talk to your insurance representative, talk to FEMA. Don't expect a lot of understanding from your floorplanner. Look at the possibility of getting an SBA loan to cover your floorplan debt.
If you get sued by your floorplan lender in Indiana, call us at 317-662-4529. The worst thing you can do is let the floorplan company get a default judgment on a lawsuit.
(Video from ABC News via youtube.com)
Monday, September 10, 2018
Like a Good Neighbor - State Farm is There - Settling a RICO Case for a Quarter of a Billion Dollars
State Farm just agreed to pay $250 MILLION dollars to settle a civil racketeering (RICO) case alleging it engaged in an enterprise for the purpose of illegally funnelling $4 million dollars in 2004 into a campaign to elect a faborable judge to the Illinois Supreme Court. That judge eventually was elected and was theeciding vote overturning a $1 billion judgment in Avery v State Farm where a class of consuemrs were awarded a big vicotry concerning improper use of none OEM repair parts.
Now if all this sounds like mumbo jumbo, it's from me trying to summarize in a paragraph things that took 20 years to happen in real life. Here's what to take from it. State Farm says it did anything wrong, but State Farm paid $250 million for the privilege of not having a court rule to the contrary. If you are a State Farm policy holder (as I used to be), this money came from your premiums. Your money, your choice.
(By the way, don't call me about this case. It wasn't my case. I just read about it.)
Here's the article.
Now if all this sounds like mumbo jumbo, it's from me trying to summarize in a paragraph things that took 20 years to happen in real life. Here's what to take from it. State Farm says it did anything wrong, but State Farm paid $250 million for the privilege of not having a court rule to the contrary. If you are a State Farm policy holder (as I used to be), this money came from your premiums. Your money, your choice.
(By the way, don't call me about this case. It wasn't my case. I just read about it.)
Here's the article.
Thursday, September 6, 2018
Consumer Advice from NCLC on How to Deal with Credit Report Problems
The National Consumer Law Center's (NCLC) primary role is to educate attorneys on consumer law issues. The NCLC also gives expert analysis and testimony to state, local and federal government and the news media. Finally, from time to time, the NCLC drafts publications giving consumers advice directly. Recently Chi Chi Wu of NCLC posted a concise yet informative article on credit reports and credit scores. Here is the link. I think this artic should be mandatory reading for college students taking personal finance classes. I am going to start sending a link to the article to every caller who asks me about credit report problems.
https://library.nclc.org/essentials-about-credit-reporting-consumer-debt-advice-nclc
https://library.nclc.org/essentials-about-credit-reporting-consumer-debt-advice-nclc
Friday, August 24, 2018
Potential Defenses to The College Network Assignees
I've been looking at some documents lately relating to a loan by Lifeway Credit Union for a LPN-to RN contract by The College Network. The College Network is a defunct Indiana firm that sold LPN-RN programs. TCN was accused of selling the programs as if they were a full class program while at the same time claiming htey were just a provider of educational material. It has come to my attention that the Credit Unions that provided capital to The College Network by funding their student accounts are still trying to collect these debts even though The College Network was run out of business for being a deeptive operation.
From what I have been able to gather, Lifeway Credit Union was a relatively-small player regarding TCN contracts. Southeast Fenderal Credit Union the most contracts and We Florida Financial Credit Union was a player. Southeast Federal Credit Union sued TCN. See this link.
If you have a debt to a credit union arising out of a contract with The College Network, you should be that if TCN referred you to the lender, any claim or defense you could raise against The College Network you can raise against your lender up to the amount of the contract. This means you MIGHT have an offensive claim to get some money back. You have an even better chance at getting out of the loan obligation and getting your credit report clear.
It seems that most of the contracts that I've seen involved either Southeast Financial Credit Union or Lifeway Credit Union. The Attorney General of New York brought an action against Southeast Financial Credit Union for disregarding the claims and defenses of the studnets. You can read about it here.
Until recently, when I have received calls about The College Network, I have referred callers to fellow NACA member attorneys in their area. Quite frankly, I have been disappointed by the results, as the lawyers I have referred the consumers to have not known what to do with the cases. I recently noticed that The College Network contract that I reviewed included a clause mandating binding arbitration in Marion County, Indiana. Now, the general rule is that binding arbitration is a disaster for consumers, BUT depending on the Arbitration agency, binding consumer arbitration may cost the business a lot more than the consumer, and may discourage a suit against the consumer. Marion County, Indiana happens to be my home county. Because of the connection to Indiana and the arbitration clause, I have decided to take on cases defending against claims by assignees of the College Network. If you are subject to collection activity relating to a College Network contract, please call me at 317-662-4529.
From what I have been able to gather, Lifeway Credit Union was a relatively-small player regarding TCN contracts. Southeast Fenderal Credit Union the most contracts and We Florida Financial Credit Union was a player. Southeast Federal Credit Union sued TCN. See this link.
If you have a debt to a credit union arising out of a contract with The College Network, you should be that if TCN referred you to the lender, any claim or defense you could raise against The College Network you can raise against your lender up to the amount of the contract. This means you MIGHT have an offensive claim to get some money back. You have an even better chance at getting out of the loan obligation and getting your credit report clear.
It seems that most of the contracts that I've seen involved either Southeast Financial Credit Union or Lifeway Credit Union. The Attorney General of New York brought an action against Southeast Financial Credit Union for disregarding the claims and defenses of the studnets. You can read about it here.
Until recently, when I have received calls about The College Network, I have referred callers to fellow NACA member attorneys in their area. Quite frankly, I have been disappointed by the results, as the lawyers I have referred the consumers to have not known what to do with the cases. I recently noticed that The College Network contract that I reviewed included a clause mandating binding arbitration in Marion County, Indiana. Now, the general rule is that binding arbitration is a disaster for consumers, BUT depending on the Arbitration agency, binding consumer arbitration may cost the business a lot more than the consumer, and may discourage a suit against the consumer. Marion County, Indiana happens to be my home county. Because of the connection to Indiana and the arbitration clause, I have decided to take on cases defending against claims by assignees of the College Network. If you are subject to collection activity relating to a College Network contract, please call me at 317-662-4529.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)