There is a surprisingly non-partisan case up in the United States Supreme Court right now, Impression Products v Lexmark, the Supreme Court is considering whether Impression Products has the right to refill and sell patented Lexmark inkjet printer cartridges. The general rule in patents is once a company with a patent sells a covered product, the sold product is not subject to additional restrictions by the patent holder.
At issue is a judicially-crafted narrow exception for products that were sold with an explicit contractual restriction. Lextmark claims that its cartridges are sold with a restriction on resell on the outer shrinkwrap of the cartridges that is supposedly supported by a 20% discount.
The Supreme Court is supposedly having a tough time deciding this case. They should let me write the opinion. Here's my rough draft:
"Lexmark's position is complete bullshit. Th. The e shrinkwrapped contract does not represent true assent. The consideration is illusory. Even if the contract not to sell was valid, restrictions on sale of printer cartridges violate the very core principles of our patent system, so to the extent that the exception is valid at all, which may need to be considered in another case, it can't be stretched to this product. "
A blog covering legal topics and whatever I feel like posting. Some posts on this page could be considered to be attorney advertisements.
About The Consumer Law Office of Steve Hofer
Steve Hofer has been practicing consumer law in Indiana for more than 20 years. He is a former Indiana State Chairperson of the National Association of Consumer Advocates, a national organization of attorneys striving for fairness in the consumer marketplace. Contact me by phone at 317-662-4529 or via email at hoferlawindyATgmail.com. You can also leave a message through my website at www.hoferlawindy.com.
Sunday, March 26, 2017
Friday, March 24, 2017
Have You Had A Vehicle Repossessed by Baam Financial, Inc.? Look at their Lawsuits
If you have impaired credit and bought a car from one of the Andy Mohr Indianapolis-area dealerships, there is a good chance that your loan was placed with BAAM Financial Inc. BAAM Financial files a lot of lawsuits in Marion county. In representing a current client, I noticed that BAAM sues for unusually high deficiencies in what would be expected to be suits involving relatively low-priced vehicles. Let me explain.
My client purchased a 2005 Nissan Altima from Andy Mohr Nissan, Inc. in May 2013. She financed $10,398.65 on this car which had over 133,000 miles on it when she purchased it. That's not a good deal, in my opinion, but it's not illegal. The car was financed with BAAM Financial at 21% interest. Again, not a good deal in my opinion, but if you have credit issues you don't always have a choice. She made payments on it (not always on-time) until September 2016, when it was repossessed by BAAM. At the time it was repossessed, there was a listed balance on the loan of $8,100.54. It is this amount that BAAM sued her for plus costs, interest and attorney fees.
Note that the record this stage doesn't reflect that BAAM recovered any proceeds from the sale after repossession of the vehicle, or that BAAM applied proceeds to the loan balance sued upon. The law is clear that after repossessing a vehicle, the lender is supposed to dispose of the vehicle in a commercially reasonable way. It is possible that an old vehicle with mechanical problems doesn't have any commercial value. If that is the case, we are going to argue in this case that it is commercially unreasonable to repossess it in the first place, and if the lender repossesses the vehicle then finds out that it has no value, we are going to argue that commercial reasonableness requires that the lender needs to give the owner a chance to reclaim the vehicle.
I did a quick survey of what happened in five other BAAM Financial cases in Marion County Indiana. All of these cases went to default judgment, so the attorney fees are not likely too high. Each one of these cases reflect what are (in my opinion) high deficiency balances for subprime credit vehicles. I don't have records to tell me what caused the high deficiencies in these cases, but based on my experience with other cases, I would guess a mixture of high initial prices plus low prices obtained on disposition. Sometimes low prices at disposition are caused by commercially unreasonable sales, and sometimes not.
Case Number Judgment Amount
49D10-1604-CC-012616 $12,314,81
49D14-1601-CC-00113 $ 8,402.18 ("and forfeiture of 2004 F150")
49D04-1601-CC-000104 $13,266.49
49D01-1001-CC-00118 $13,370.49
49D01-1601-CC-00110 $ 8406.63
In summary, the amounts they are claiming after all credits were applied including after the sale of the car, looks a lot like what the car sold for originally, This isn't right, and judgments like these can be the financial deathblow to a struggling individual or family.
If you are currently being sued by Baam Financial, please talk to a lawyer. You need to make sure your rights are protected. You need to make sure that the vehicle was sold in a commerically reasonable way and that the proceeds of the sale were applied to your balance. If the finance company did not sell your vehicle in a commercially reasonable way (and getting an unusually low price at resale is often a result), you may be able to defend completely or partially against a lawsuit claiming a deficiency. In certain cases, you may be able to raise a claim for damages and attorney fees to be paid by the other side.
IF YOU HAVE BEEN SUED BY BAAM FINANCIAL, INC., EVEN IF YOUR CASE WENT TO JUDGMENT, I WILL REVIEW YOUR PAPERWORK AT NO CHARGE TO YOU. PLEASE CALL ME AT 317-662-4529 OR EMAIL ME AT HOFERLAWINDY@GMAIL.COM.
My client purchased a 2005 Nissan Altima from Andy Mohr Nissan, Inc. in May 2013. She financed $10,398.65 on this car which had over 133,000 miles on it when she purchased it. That's not a good deal, in my opinion, but it's not illegal. The car was financed with BAAM Financial at 21% interest. Again, not a good deal in my opinion, but if you have credit issues you don't always have a choice. She made payments on it (not always on-time) until September 2016, when it was repossessed by BAAM. At the time it was repossessed, there was a listed balance on the loan of $8,100.54. It is this amount that BAAM sued her for plus costs, interest and attorney fees.
Note that the record this stage doesn't reflect that BAAM recovered any proceeds from the sale after repossession of the vehicle, or that BAAM applied proceeds to the loan balance sued upon. The law is clear that after repossessing a vehicle, the lender is supposed to dispose of the vehicle in a commercially reasonable way. It is possible that an old vehicle with mechanical problems doesn't have any commercial value. If that is the case, we are going to argue in this case that it is commercially unreasonable to repossess it in the first place, and if the lender repossesses the vehicle then finds out that it has no value, we are going to argue that commercial reasonableness requires that the lender needs to give the owner a chance to reclaim the vehicle.
I did a quick survey of what happened in five other BAAM Financial cases in Marion County Indiana. All of these cases went to default judgment, so the attorney fees are not likely too high. Each one of these cases reflect what are (in my opinion) high deficiency balances for subprime credit vehicles. I don't have records to tell me what caused the high deficiencies in these cases, but based on my experience with other cases, I would guess a mixture of high initial prices plus low prices obtained on disposition. Sometimes low prices at disposition are caused by commercially unreasonable sales, and sometimes not.
Case Number Judgment Amount
49D10-1604-CC-012616 $12,314,81
49D14-1601-CC-00113 $ 8,402.18 ("and forfeiture of 2004 F150")
49D04-1601-CC-000104 $13,266.49
49D01-1001-CC-00118 $13,370.49
49D01-1601-CC-00110 $ 8406.63
In summary, the amounts they are claiming after all credits were applied including after the sale of the car, looks a lot like what the car sold for originally, This isn't right, and judgments like these can be the financial deathblow to a struggling individual or family.
If you are currently being sued by Baam Financial, please talk to a lawyer. You need to make sure your rights are protected. You need to make sure that the vehicle was sold in a commerically reasonable way and that the proceeds of the sale were applied to your balance. If the finance company did not sell your vehicle in a commercially reasonable way (and getting an unusually low price at resale is often a result), you may be able to defend completely or partially against a lawsuit claiming a deficiency. In certain cases, you may be able to raise a claim for damages and attorney fees to be paid by the other side.
IF YOU HAVE BEEN SUED BY BAAM FINANCIAL, INC., EVEN IF YOUR CASE WENT TO JUDGMENT, I WILL REVIEW YOUR PAPERWORK AT NO CHARGE TO YOU. PLEASE CALL ME AT 317-662-4529 OR EMAIL ME AT HOFERLAWINDY@GMAIL.COM.
Monday, March 20, 2017
Have You Been Sued by LVNV on an Out-of-State Judgment
I have a case where LVNV Funding, LLC, filed to have a Tennessee judgment issued in the name of the original creditor converted into an Indiana Judgment in the name of LVNV. We are currently fighting this. If you are involved in a similar case, even in totally different states, please call me. I'm not really interested in getting more clients on this. What I want to do is to find out if LVNV is filing a lot of these.
Parent of CACH LLC files for Bankruptcy
Square Two Financial Corporation, the parent company of bad debt buyer CACH LCC, has filed Chapter 11 bankruptcy. From the looks of it, this was a "prepackaged" bankruptcy, with Resurgent Holdings LLC waiting in the wings to buy up the assets of the company.
If you are being sued by CACH LLC, your case is expected to go on without interruption. There may be a snag in getting documents (even more than usual) because of the need to integrate CACH's record system with Resurgent's.
If you are suing CACH, then you have my sympathy. Your case will likely be caught up in the bankruptcy and likely be stalled for a good long while at best.
In my opinion, Resurgent (and its subsidiary LVNV) is neither better nor worse than CACH, so from a consumer's point of view, it's probably neutral.
Of course, the irony in this is debt collectors are notorious for ridiculing consumers about not being able to handle their finances, yet CACH has joined the list of collectors that bought debt at 5 cents on the dollar which couldn't meet their obligations.
If you are being sued on a consumer debt in Indiana, please call the Consumer Law Office of Steve Hofer. I will evaluate your case at no cost to you.
If you are being sued by CACH LLC, your case is expected to go on without interruption. There may be a snag in getting documents (even more than usual) because of the need to integrate CACH's record system with Resurgent's.
If you are suing CACH, then you have my sympathy. Your case will likely be caught up in the bankruptcy and likely be stalled for a good long while at best.
In my opinion, Resurgent (and its subsidiary LVNV) is neither better nor worse than CACH, so from a consumer's point of view, it's probably neutral.
Of course, the irony in this is debt collectors are notorious for ridiculing consumers about not being able to handle their finances, yet CACH has joined the list of collectors that bought debt at 5 cents on the dollar which couldn't meet their obligations.
If you are being sued on a consumer debt in Indiana, please call the Consumer Law Office of Steve Hofer. I will evaluate your case at no cost to you.
Thursday, March 16, 2017
How to Record Debt Collection Calls on iPhone and Android
Often, to build a good legal case under the Fair Debt Collection Practices Act (FDCPA) or Telephone Consumer Privacy Act (TCPA) it is helpful - sometimes crucial- to have recorded phone calls. Back in formative years with landlines, we did this with either a suction cup adapter or inline box from radio shack - going into a cassette recorder. Of course these days, cell phones - smart phones - rule, so recording is a bit more complicated - or not.
The simplest way to record a phone call now is to put the phone on speaker phone, and just record into another phone's memo recording app.
There are more complicated methods. Here's a recently-updated webpage discussing recording on iPhone. http://www.digitaltrends.com/mobile/how-to-record-calls-iphone/
Here's a 2016 article with 5 call recording apps for Android. http://joyofandroid.com/best-android-call-recorder-apps/
Remember that when you are recording phone calls you have to pay attention to wiretapping laws. You can NEVER record a phone conversation where you are not one of the participants in the call. That is true wiretapping. Most states are "single party" states which means if one party (you) is aware of the recording, it is legal to record the call, even without telling the other party. A few states are "two party" consent states where both parties have to consent to the recording. According to information I found on the web, the following states are two-party consent states: California, Connecticut, Florida, Illinois, Maryland, Massachusetts, Montana, New Hampshire, Pennsylvania, and Washington. If you are in a one-party state and you record a call where the other party is in a two-party state, you won't be prosecuted for the call, but there may be limitations on how you can use it.
The simplest way to record a phone call now is to put the phone on speaker phone, and just record into another phone's memo recording app.
There are more complicated methods. Here's a recently-updated webpage discussing recording on iPhone. http://www.digitaltrends.com/mobile/how-to-record-calls-iphone/
Here's a 2016 article with 5 call recording apps for Android. http://joyofandroid.com/best-android-call-recorder-apps/
Remember that when you are recording phone calls you have to pay attention to wiretapping laws. You can NEVER record a phone conversation where you are not one of the participants in the call. That is true wiretapping. Most states are "single party" states which means if one party (you) is aware of the recording, it is legal to record the call, even without telling the other party. A few states are "two party" consent states where both parties have to consent to the recording. According to information I found on the web, the following states are two-party consent states: California, Connecticut, Florida, Illinois, Maryland, Massachusetts, Montana, New Hampshire, Pennsylvania, and Washington. If you are in a one-party state and you record a call where the other party is in a two-party state, you won't be prosecuted for the call, but there may be limitations on how you can use it.
Tuesday, March 14, 2017
Nonbank Servicers Causing Havoc with Troubled Homeowners
The New York Post recently published an article about a troubling phenomenon that I have not seen anywhere else in the mainstream press, and that is the rise of nonbank servicers (NBS) handling home mortgages. I ran into this first a number of years ago with Ocwen Home Servicing. Ocwen got slapped pretty hard in 2012-2013 by the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau & the California Attorney General, agreeing to pay fines and penalties of several billion dollars.
The New York Post article points out that nonbank servicers have gone from 7% of the market in 2012 to 25% in 2015. I would guess that at this point the NBS share of mortgages that are in foreclosure or preforeclosure is probably around 50% and rising. This is important because the NBSs are not subject to the terms of the national mortgage settlement. This is important because as a general rule a company holding a mortgage has no duty to modify to prevent foreclosure. The national mortgage settlement created a framework for evaluating applications for mortgage relief, standards for granting relief, and prohibited moving forward with foreclosure while a mortgage relief application was pending - a practice called "dual-tracking". Other than the mortgage settlement, the only real mandates for modification come from the rules of the mortgage insurers, and those are a joke. There are state laws that attempt to impose penalties for unfair practices in mortgage servicing, but there are more holes than fabric in the patchwork quilt of state laws.
The big daddy these days among the nonbank servicers is Caliber Home Loans. Caliber is starting to draw some scrutiny for the way it is servicing loans, and it has been the subject of numerous complaints by consumers whose applications for mortgage relief were either mishandled, ignored or both. Caliber is the servicing arm of Loan Star Funds, a private equity firm that if you believe the New York Post article is worth $60 billion. Lone Star Funds got this big because they buy troubled mortgages at a discount, usually from insurers who already covered the initiating bank's losses, entities like FHA, Freddie Mac and Fannie Mae. If you have a loan that was bought by LSF9 Master Participation Trust. That's a Lone Star fund. Sometimes Lone Star doesn't buy the loan from the guarantor, it buys it from the actual lender. I have received complaints that the homeowner's mortgage was sold by the original mortgage company to LSF9 where the foreclosure took place and then back to the original mortgage company. In my opinion, that is a whitewashing scam that is designed to get around the rules of the National Mortgage Settlement. If you had a Wells Fargo loan that was sold to LSF9 Master Participation Trust or had its servicing transferred to Caliber Home Loans, you should pay attention to what happens to it after the foreclosure sale. You may have a very narrow window to make your complaints count and perhaps bring a legal claim between the time the home is sold to the lender after the foreclosure and the time you are forced to vacate. If this has happened to you, you need to file a complaint with the CFPB and your state attorney general. Find yourself a NACA consumer advocate lawyer at www.consumeradvocates.org.
http://nypost.com/2016/04/16/non-bank-servicers-creating-bigger-mortgage-problems/?utm_source=facebook&utm_medium=site%20buttons&utm_campaign=site%20buttons
The New York Post article points out that nonbank servicers have gone from 7% of the market in 2012 to 25% in 2015. I would guess that at this point the NBS share of mortgages that are in foreclosure or preforeclosure is probably around 50% and rising. This is important because the NBSs are not subject to the terms of the national mortgage settlement. This is important because as a general rule a company holding a mortgage has no duty to modify to prevent foreclosure. The national mortgage settlement created a framework for evaluating applications for mortgage relief, standards for granting relief, and prohibited moving forward with foreclosure while a mortgage relief application was pending - a practice called "dual-tracking". Other than the mortgage settlement, the only real mandates for modification come from the rules of the mortgage insurers, and those are a joke. There are state laws that attempt to impose penalties for unfair practices in mortgage servicing, but there are more holes than fabric in the patchwork quilt of state laws.
The big daddy these days among the nonbank servicers is Caliber Home Loans. Caliber is starting to draw some scrutiny for the way it is servicing loans, and it has been the subject of numerous complaints by consumers whose applications for mortgage relief were either mishandled, ignored or both. Caliber is the servicing arm of Loan Star Funds, a private equity firm that if you believe the New York Post article is worth $60 billion. Lone Star Funds got this big because they buy troubled mortgages at a discount, usually from insurers who already covered the initiating bank's losses, entities like FHA, Freddie Mac and Fannie Mae. If you have a loan that was bought by LSF9 Master Participation Trust. That's a Lone Star fund. Sometimes Lone Star doesn't buy the loan from the guarantor, it buys it from the actual lender. I have received complaints that the homeowner's mortgage was sold by the original mortgage company to LSF9 where the foreclosure took place and then back to the original mortgage company. In my opinion, that is a whitewashing scam that is designed to get around the rules of the National Mortgage Settlement. If you had a Wells Fargo loan that was sold to LSF9 Master Participation Trust or had its servicing transferred to Caliber Home Loans, you should pay attention to what happens to it after the foreclosure sale. You may have a very narrow window to make your complaints count and perhaps bring a legal claim between the time the home is sold to the lender after the foreclosure and the time you are forced to vacate. If this has happened to you, you need to file a complaint with the CFPB and your state attorney general. Find yourself a NACA consumer advocate lawyer at www.consumeradvocates.org.
http://nypost.com/2016/04/16/non-bank-servicers-creating-bigger-mortgage-problems/?utm_source=facebook&utm_medium=site%20buttons&utm_campaign=site%20buttons
Update Regarding LSF9 Master Participation Trust
My most popular post ever on this blog had to do with LSF9 Master Participation trust. I have been contacted by numerous people who either are facing foreclosure on an LSF9 Property or want to buy a distressed LSF9 property. It has gotten to the point where these calls are interfering with my business. Still, I understand people are craving information. I wish I had more to give them. I put together this update to my post of 9/2015 which I also appended to the original post. There are some good comments on the original post. So if you see this post. please go to the original post here.
UPDATE 3/14/2017
Since I wrote this blog post a year and a half ago, it has been by far my most popular post, with over 14,000 hits. I have also gotten emails from lots of frustrated people trying to deal with LSF-9. Most of these have either been people who are either trying to buy LSF9 properties or who are facing foreclosure on an LSF-9 mortgage. I have this to say about each category:
IF YOU ARE FACING FORECLOSURE ON A MORTGAGE OWNED BY LSF9 Master Participation Trust, or maybe LSF8 or LSF10 or whatever, get advice from an experienced consumer lawyer IN YOUR AREA. To find one in your area use the National Association of Consumer Advocates' Find an Attorney page. I can't represent you if you are not a resident of Indiana.
IF YOU ARE TRYING TO BUY A PROPERTY OWNED BY LSF-9 AND CAN'T FIND ANYBODY TO CONTACT, good luck, I can't help you. You can write to Caliber. You can write to the lawyer handling the foreclosure case. You can write to Lone Star Funds, the parent company, at the address below which I took from their website.
UPDATE 3/14/2017
Since I wrote this blog post a year and a half ago, it has been by far my most popular post, with over 14,000 hits. I have also gotten emails from lots of frustrated people trying to deal with LSF-9. Most of these have either been people who are either trying to buy LSF9 properties or who are facing foreclosure on an LSF-9 mortgage. I have this to say about each category:
IF YOU ARE FACING FORECLOSURE ON A MORTGAGE OWNED BY LSF9 Master Participation Trust, or maybe LSF8 or LSF10 or whatever, get advice from an experienced consumer lawyer IN YOUR AREA. To find one in your area use the National Association of Consumer Advocates' Find an Attorney page. I can't represent you if you are not a resident of Indiana.
IF YOU ARE TRYING TO BUY A PROPERTY OWNED BY LSF-9 AND CAN'T FIND ANYBODY TO CONTACT, good luck, I can't help you. You can write to Caliber. You can write to the lawyer handling the foreclosure case. You can write to Lone Star Funds, the parent company, at the address below which I took from their website.
Lone Star Global Acquisitions, Ltd.
- Lone Star North America Acquisitions, LLC
2711 North Haskell AvenueSuite 1700 (and Suite 2150)Dallas, Texas 75204USA214-754-8300
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)