About The Consumer Law Office of Steve Hofer

Steve Hofer has been practicing consumer law in Indiana for more than 20 years. He is a former Indiana State Chairperson of the National Association of Consumer Advocates, a national organization of attorneys striving for fairness in the consumer marketplace. Contact me by phone at 317-662-4529 or via email at hoferlawindyATgmail.com. You can also leave a message through my website at www.hoferlawindy.com.

Tuesday, July 21, 2020

Art Institute of Indianapolis and Elements Financial Federal Credit Union - Possibility of Private Student Loan Assistance

I was vaguely aware of the Art Institutes, that it was a big conglomerate of private for-profit colleges, that it shut down in 2018, and that there was a plan for forgiveness of certain federal student loans due to alleged fraud by the university.  Until recently though, I had never been contacted by one of the students.

That changed this week.  An issue came up regarding a private student loan through Elements Financial federal Credit Uunion for the Art Institute of Indianapolis.  

It appears that the Art Institute may have referred students to Elements Financial, if so, students may have an argument under the FTC Holder Rule that any claim they would have against Art Institute might be raised as a defense or partial defense against repayment to Elements Financial.  

This is a complex topic.  If you went to Art Institute of Indianapolis and were financed by Elements Financial or any other lender that was referred to you by the school, I am interested in talking to you, and we might have a shot at getting you some help.  Note that right now I am not dealing in cases involving FEDERAL student loans. 

If you went to any other Art Institute, or have issues regarding federal student loans, I urge you to contact an attorney in your area through the NACA consumer lawyer referral service at www.consumeradvocates.org/find-an-attorney.  

A general information article I found is linked below. I cannot vouch for the accuracy of the entire article, so get a second source before acting on anything contained in this link. 

Sunday, July 12, 2020

Legal Fees in Perspective $2,750 vs $2.75 million - Bill Cosby

A news story today that Bill Cosby still owes $2.75 million in legal fees. We have no idea how much he paid over time, but there is no question that Bill Cosby was not a poor man going into his criminal case, I would expect that the unpaid balance is less than half of what the representation ultimately cost.

What strikes me is the disparity in resources people can put into different legal cases. I do a lot of consumer and business debt defense cases.  My fees for a standard business case range from $2,500 to $5000, because that's all the businesses can afford. For consumer cases, my fees are sometimes lower - when I can afford to do those cases.  That's on the order of 1/1000 what Bill Cosby put into his criminal defense case -- or to put it another way, for every 1 hour I can put into a case, Bill Cosby's lawyers put in a half year's worth of work - and he still lost. 

What I have learned is to make a defense case useful and worthwhile on a budget, you have to carefully plan your strategy. You must have well-defined goals and objectives, and a pathway to get there. 

Monday, June 15, 2020

Nextgear and AFC updates in Covid Time

We continue to handle a lot of floorplan defense lawsuits, defending dealers sued by Nextgear and AFC.  They are still filing new cases even though the court systems have been slowed by COVID-19.  In general, our perception is that Nextgear has been willing to work with us in recognizing the new reality of Covid-affected dealers.  AFC has been much more difficult. 

Tuesday, June 9, 2020

Body Attachments for Contempt of Court in Indiana, Some Welcome Changes

For years, Indiana has been a center for injustice regarding the issuance of body attachments for unpaid civil judgments.  A body attachment is basically an arrest. Technically, it is not for failure to pay the judgment, rather, it is for contempt of court for failing to attend a proceeding supplemental to judgment to give information to the plaintiff for purposes of collecting the judgment. That being said there are a number of legitimate reasons why a person might not attend a proceeding supplemental. The most common is they never know about the proceeding supplemental in the first place. Other reasons might be lack of child care, lack of transportation, inability to read and understand the legal pleadings, illness or general incompetence. 

Both federal and state law prohibits imprisonment for debt. Section 22 of the Indiana Constitution provides as follows:

Section 22. Debts--Imprisonment exemption

Section 22. The privilege of the debtor to enjoy the necessary comforts of life, shall be recognized by wholesome laws, exempting a reasonable amount of property from seizure or sale, for the payment of any debt or liability hereafter contracted: and there shall be no imprisonment for debt, except in case of fraud.

For at least as long as I've been an attorney, 33 years and counting, courts have issued body attachments in the form of a bench warrant, an arrest warrant. . It has worked differently in different counties, but if a law enforcement officer seizes the person, the law enforcement officer is supposed to take the person to the court, for questioning about why the person did not attend the proceeding supplemental.  On many occasions the person was seized and the court was not in session, so the person had to stay in jail over a weekend, sometimes an extended holiday weekend. 

In recent years there has been some attention in the press to the issue of poor people spending time in jail because they can't pay civil judgments, and it looks like it is finally starting to pay dividends in court rules. Today I was reading Delaware County's local rules in preparation for a case, and I found out that they recently adopted rules greatly reducing the power to issue a bench warrant on a civil judgment.  Essentially the defendant has to prove actual notice and if the warrant is issued, it must be done during court hours and the defendant is taken directly to the court. 

If you are subjected to a body attachment relating to a civil judgment in Indiana, we will talk to you and look into your claim at no charge.  Often plaintiffs and their attorneys make mistakes in the process, and these mistakes could give you the opportunity to collect damages in a lawsuit.  Please call us at 317-662-4529 if you have any questions.  

Monday, June 8, 2020

Lenovo Flex-14 screen flickeringI

Late last year my main Lenovo laptop had to go in the shop. To get me by while it was out of service I bought a smaller, lighter, cheaper computer, a Lenovo Flex-14 "2 in 1". It was under $550, and I've generally been happy with it, but it has an occasional screen flickering. The screen will momentarily go black.  In my family, we have had Dell, Samsung, Asus and Lenovo Computers knocked out over screen issues, so I googled to see if this was a big problem with the Flex 14, and googling "Flex 14" and "flickering" yields 403,000 hits. 

Based on the hassles of backing up, packaging and shipping my other Lenovo machine twice for warranty repair, right now I don't think the problem is sufficiently bad enough to send back my computer.  I'm keeping an eye on it.

I don't have an intention of filing a lawsuit against Lenovo or even taking on one as a lawyer. To assist folks that might need to file one, I found this lawsuit against Lenovo for a claimed screen defect in the Flex 5 from 2017.  Here is the link.  https://www.classaction.org/media/gisairo-v-lenovo-united-states-inc.pdf.  This isn't my case. I have nothing to do with it.  For more information, contact the lawyer on the complaint. 

(For the Apple fanboys out there. We have had a number of Macbook Pros and Macbook Airs over the years, and most of our problems with those machines have been limited to bad external power supplies and cords to the power supplies.  Well, that and a Macbook Pro 13 would cost about three times what I paid for the Lenovo Flex 14.)

Monday, May 18, 2020

Chapter 5 Bankruptcy may be just the lifeline that troubled small businesses need.

Since I don't practice bankruptcy law, I am just now learning about the new Chapter 5 bankruptcy provision that went into effect February 2020.  Subchapter 5 is intended to be a simplified and less-costly alternative to a Chapter 11 reorganization. 

Chapter 5 is much like a Chapter 11, but there is no creditors committee. Effectively, it is a cram-down like Chapter 13. 

I still have to learn about how personal guarantees of business debt are handled because most of my small-business debt defense clients signed personal guarantees of the business's debt.  If creditors are allowed to bring action against the guarantors while the bankruptcy is pending it may be of little use.  We'll see. 

Here is a link to a bankruptcy law firm's explanation of Chapter 5. I am not associated with this firm, and I can't guarantee the accuracy of the. information given. Anyone interested in Chapter 5 should verify all information before acting upon it. 

https://rcbizjournal.com/2020/03/23/new-bankruptcy-law-could-be-a-blessing-in-upcoming-economic-blizzard/

Tuesday, May 12, 2020

Fears of "Death Trains" may support surprisingly robust COVID-19 car sales

There is speculaton that at least in some areas new and used car sales may be surprisingly robust even with business shutdowns and high unemployment due to the corona virus.  I totally get why people might get concerned commuting by train or bus before there is a vaccination for COVID-19. 

https://www.thetruthaboutcars.com/2020/05/death-train-vs-safe-car-sales-hypothesis-gains-new-evidence/